A devastating side effect of helping people who don’t need your help. Consider that tweaks could be made as to when to help – or comment, or take over, or criticise, judge or teach…
One of the most important experiences a person needs for a satisfying, successful, healthy life.
A sense of: “I can do this.”
More importantly: “I can learn this.”
Competence is an encouraging (quite possibly positively addictive) experience of success, that inspires further stretching of skills. Then those, along with the inherent extra learning strategies too, can be add to the list of a person’s long list of competencies.
The most important competence experience is the repeatable ability to learn new skills. This is mostly achieved by grappling with physical, emotional & mental learning processes, mostly alone.
To illustrate, you’ve heard the phrase: “You can lead a horse to water. You can’t make them drink.” The drinking process MUST be entirely facilitated by the horse. Otherwise it’s just force-feeding, and nothing truly good ever came of that.
It’s the same with humans learning and completing tasks. And the downward spiral begins, though is not limited to, young childhood.
Young humans are wired to struggle with tasks and keep going (ever watched a child teach themselves to walk?!) They’ll find unique and more or less efficient and effective ways to drink the water without even needing to be led to the ideal watering holes. No forcing and usually only minimal (if any) support and encouragement required.
This innate ability to LEARN competence flows strongly … until children take on, as their own, the limiting, meaning-making and negative mindsets of people around them. These bystanders externalise their fears, due to their own inability to handle the discomfort of watching someone else’s uncomfortable learning stages. They dive in to help because they do not like how they feel, and desperately want the struggling person to be able to do the task. In doing so they deprive the learner of the struggle AND the sense of competence.
· Free to demonstrate what you can do in the ways that are right for you
· Allowed to learn from your mistakes without judgement or others’ fears interfering
· Supported to learn from your mistakes with space, time and maybe small nudges on request
· Confident in your current capability and your potential to learn more
· Appreciative of the long game, rather than knocked off the learning course at first stumble or seemingly insurmountable obstacle
· Feeling satisfied with your progress or the outcomes you’re creating
Let’s play this out with a wee scenario:
Consider Anna who is trying to do something she hasn’t done before very successfully. She’s working on new skills to achieve this task. She’s finding it difficult to complete to her satisfaction. Anna is needing to dig deep into herself, problem solve, try out different mindsets about keeping going and doing things differently, despite the many mistakes she’s making.
Anna is learning who she is now in relation to what she’s trying to achieve and how she’s transforming herself to achieve it.
Feelings of Competence are eroded when other people:
· Take over the task without asking, being asked, or their help accepted
· Interfere with the person’s natural learning processes
· Don’t see the benefits of what is being done or learned
· Offer assistance too early, giving the other person an easy out that is tempting when the task is getting tough
· Question what’s being done without understanding what the focus, process or vision currently are
· Judge based on their own expectations
· Thrust their fears onto the person, which can limit their vision for themselves
· Feel intimidated and so seek to keep the person small
· Need to feel needed so seek to keep the person small
· Give options but only really mean them to make “the right” choice
· Convince the person that they cannot possibly do this big thing…
NB: Many, if not most, of these are unintended and/or unconscious actions and beliefs disguised as “I need to help them.” or “They need my help.”
Back to the scenario:
You are Anna’s friend and finding it really uncomfortable to watch her struggle – though you do not recognise this feeling in yourself. What crosses your mind instead is: “Anna can’t do this. She needs my help. I must help else I’m not a good friend.”
So you say: “Hey, Anna, you need to do this instead. If you keep going like that, you’ll never manage it. No sense wasting your time and energy, huh? Here, let me do it. I know what to do and I’m good at it. You’ll feel much better when it’s all done.”
True, you may get away with one-offs. Over time though the person’s drive to try, keep going through the struggle, believe in their own competence, reduces under a powerful wave of: “Others do it better than me, I’d best not try.” They seek others to do it for them or pretend they don’t even need it rather than risk failure. This becomes a pattern that is then embedded across many areas of life.
Learned helplessness is born.
The person feels…
· Doubt about their own skills and potential
· Small, less, pathetic or needy, like a victim
· Convinced they cannot possibly do this small thing (let alone the really big things they used to dream of)
· There’s no point in trying to problem solve themselves, instead wait for help
· That there is a “right” way that they don’t understand or aren’t skilled at
· It’s not worth telling others of goals that they don’t believe in or get
· There are other, lesser, goals that are more within grasp, so best shoot for them
· Expansive dreams are not worth even dreaming of any more…
Well, this all feels very dim and grim. What can be done instead?
Every person’s greatest need is to be seen and heard for who they truly are. This means that being truly supportive of someone starts with assuming they are competent – even if this is in a set of skills you do not fully understand, or even value. Trust in their competence. Believe in them.
Next, pause long enough to observe what they are doing, feeling and trying to achieve:
· Big and smaller picture goals and all the transformation in between.
· Notice how they look and guess their current feelings and experience.
· Accept these states as true and valuable for them.
· Recognise what stage they are in on their learning journey.
· Allow them to be at this stage.
At the same time, you’ll work on being authentically aware of your own current feelings and experience:
· Does it feel uncomfortable watching someone you care about struggle?
· Do you want to help them for them, or for you?
· If you’re sure you want to help them for them, have they given you a clear indication that this assumption is correct, that they really do need your help in this moment?
· If so, how much help will be the minimum, such that they can get back into the driver’s seat?
· What could happen if you smiled kindly and went on your way?
People wish to be supported just enough to feel, and enjoy that feeling of, competence and satisfaction at completion of a task.
They need to be allowed to feel competent.
That feeling is all the sweeter the more they are able to do on their own, especially when the learning processes were a large part of that completion journey.
Now is the time to act (or not to act):
· Acknowledge what you’re seeing; sincerely and supportively. Avoid your own judgements or expectations leaking in.
· Pause and notice how they respond to your “seeing” of them. Recheck all of the above.
o If they ask for your help, offer less rather than more – you can always do more if it’s needed
o If they put their head down and keep going, leave them to it
o If they get annoyed with you chiming in, take the hint, leave them to it and choose your moment better next time
How could this look with Anna?
Instead of the earlier learned-helplessness-making previous statement, here’s one of many possibilities…
You: “Wow Anna. You’re really working hard on that.”
Anna: “Yeah, it’s been a hard slog. I’m getting a bit confused at the moment.”
You: “That sounds hard. It’s tough when it’s not so clear what to do next. If you’d like any help, I’m just over here.”
Anna: “Hmmm. OK, I’m just trying something. Can I chat to you if it doesn’t work? I’m keen for some more ideas.”
You: “Sure.”
There are thousands of “Choose your own adventure” possible outcomes to this common scenario. Have a practice with different ways of engaging with other people who are struggling to learn something new and add this ability for helping people just the right amount to your list of competencies.
Over time...
kiaora@sarahamy.nz
+64 21 1174 899
© Copyright 2024 Sarah Amy Glensor Best | All Rights Reserved